![You Can’t Blame Trucks for the Highland Rest Area Bus Crash [Commentary] - On the Road](https://i0.wp.com/www.loadzpro.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/You-Cant-Blame-Trucks-for-the-Highland-Rest-Area-Bus.jpg?fit=1200%2C604&ssl=1)
You Can’t Blame Vans for the Highland Relaxation Space Bus Crash [Commentary] – On the Street
The crash occurred about 100 yards past the purpose the off-ramp diverged from the freeway. The vans weren’t parked on the paved portion of I-70.
Display seize, KMOV Information CBS St. Louis
I’m wondering if the current Greyhound bus crash close to Highland, Illinois, will convey our nationwide truck parking drawback into sharper focus? I’m wondering too, if an incident like this may lastly immediate the Federal Motor Service Security Administration to take a look at constructing some flexibility into the hours-of-service laws.
Earlier this month, a passenger bus struck three tractor-trailers parked alongside an exit ramp main right into a relaxation space on Interstate 70 east of St. Louis. Three bus passengers died. Others sustained critical accidents.
The Nationwide Transportation Security Board is investigating this incident. Board member Tom Chapman stated throughout a press briefing the company has an curiosity in relaxation space security. He didn’t get into specifics, save to say they’re already investigating a earlier incident that occurred in Oregon in Could.
Whereas not a lot is publicly recognized in regards to the Highland incident at this level, it troubles me that the vans are being scapegoated on this incident. The vans didn’t trigger the crash; they have been incidental. I’ll go as far as to say if it wasn’t for these vans, the result might need been worse.
What We Don’t Know Concerning the Crash
Earlier than we begin throwing blame round, we’d like think about just a few questions:
What was the bus doing on the off-ramp main into the remainder space? The collision happened a few hundred yards past the purpose the place the appropriate journey lane of the freeway and the remainder space entrance ramp diverge. The vans weren’t parked on the traveled portion of the freeway itself.
Was the bus driver asleep on the wheel? We don’t but know if the bus driver was navigating the off-ramp lane with the intention of creating a cease on the relaxation space, or if he drifted off the freeway following roughly the trail of the off-ramp.
Was the off-ramp obstructed by the parked vans? Drone pictures gathered by native tv information crews the morning after the crash clearly reveals two of the three vans have been parked nicely off the traveled portion of the remainder space off-ramp. It’s inconceivable to find out the unique place of the third truck, the rear-most truck, from the morning-after footage.
Drone photographs present the truck jackknifed up in opposition to the ahead parked truck, with the again of the trailer damaged open, apparently by the impression of the bus. That truck was clearly the preliminary level of impression and was not in its unique place. Investigators could need to depend on tire marks on the pavement to find out the place it was parked. One witness account I learn suggests the off-ramp lane was not obstructed by the parked vans simply previous to the crash.
Varied commentators have vilified the three truckers for parking on the off-ramp, suggesting their presence there contributed to 3 fatalities. Earlier than I deal with that, think about:
- If the bus driver was asleep on the wheel and was drifting proper, had the vans not been there the bus might need continued veering proper and wound up operating down a berm, which could have brought on it to roll over.
- The vans have been a presence on the roadway, like another automobile, shifting or parked. Or like a deer, or piece of particles on the roadway. An alert bus driver ought to fairly have been anticipated to have the ability to keep away from the obstruction — until there have been extenuating circumstances.
Off-Ramp Parking
Vans that park on freeway off-ramps stay a priority. It’s an unsafe follow, illustrated exactly by what occurred on the Highland relaxation space. Automobiles exiting the freeway, typically at excessive pace, run the chance of colliding with autos parked alongside the off-ramp.
Within the best-case situation, if all of the parked vans are nicely off the traveled portion of the street, they need to pose no danger in any respect. However we’ve all seen vans parked haphazardly, with noses and tails protruding on the street. Since we will’t guard in opposition to that, the follow ought to be banned and vigorously enforced.
In my view, the exits from the remainder space main again to the freeway are considerably safer. Automobiles leaving the remainder space are usually not touring at excessive pace till they attain the merge with the freeway.
The exit ramp from the westbound Silver Lake relaxation space may present parking for 20-25 extra vans if such lanes have been safely configured for parking.
Display seize, Google Maps
A scan of this relaxation space with Google Maps reveals 21 truck parking areas within the westbound Silver Lake relaxation space. The ramp main again to the freeway from the parking space may most likely accommodate about 20-25 vans. It has a shoulder on the left aspect of the ramp, and additional alongside, and shoulder on the right-hand aspect.
The shoulder is slim, and cut up pavement/gravel, but when the on-ramp was widened and paved, the theoretical capability of that website may very well be nearly doubled.
Officers may even go a step additional and paint traces designating the shoulder space as parking websites and putting in signage to that impact. That might be a lot inexpensive than constructing one other total relaxation space. And let’s be trustworthy: Vans already park there. Why don’t we do all we will to make that follow as secure as attainable?
Drivers have been parking on freeway and relaxation space on- and off-ramps so long as I can bear in mind. I began driving again in 1978. That’s 45 years, and I’m fairly certain the follow began lengthy earlier than I got here alongside. We have now been stewing over the best way to resolve the issues for many years. Possibly it’s time we acquired over it and began take into consideration methods to make it work.
My recommendations could be to widen these shoulders to allow them to safely accommodate vans, set the pave shoulder again at the very least just a few ft from the street, paint traces on the bottom to stipulate a parking stall, and at last, prohibit parking on the inbound lanes to the remainder space, whereas encouraging drivers to park on the on-ramps.
I feel rather a lot may very well be performed by way of making the most effective use of the out there actual property in lots of relaxation areas throughout the nation. As I illustrated right here, the capability may very well be doubled at a fraction of the price of a brand new facility. And it certain would take years of political wrangling to get these extra areas constructed.
ELDs Want Some Flexibility
The necessity for flexibility with digital logging gadgets has been certainly one of my main objections to mandating ELDs. I’ve no points with digital recording of drivers’ hours of service, however exhausting wiring the top of the driving shift is an extremely short-sighted and admittedly, dumb, concept. And this situation performs out hundreds of occasions each single evening on this nation.
Confronted with a sure and indelible violation for exceeding the each day and probably weekly driving limits, drivers should weigh the implications of parking at doubtlessly unsafe areas, or probably giving up out there driving time by stopping early to safe an out there parking spot.
Figures revealed in numerous reviews recommend drivers surrender a median of 56 minutes of driving time per day, or as much as $5,500 in potential earnings per 12 months. That comes with a commensurate loss in truck productiveness, too. That serves no one nicely.
Delivering that flexibility wouldn’t be terribly tough, technically, however I believe the protection advocates would don’t have any a part of this.
The best way I see it, if a driver needed to exceed the each day restrict by as much as, say, half-hour, she or he must surrender that very same period of time the next driving shift, ending it half-hour early. It will be simple sufficient to trace electronically, and it could be of no explicit benefit from a productiveness perspective. It will merely permit a bit extra time to discover a secure place to park with out placing the driving force in violation.
The security advocates have been under no circumstances glad when drivers’ workdays have been prolonged to 11 hours of driving. They predicted all kinds of calamities, which haven’t come to cross. They appear to consider that drivers flip into pumpkins on the stroke of 11, however that after all is ridiculous.
Borrowing half-hour from the following driving shift may present drivers a bit extra flexibility, however even that gained’t be sufficient in lots of circumstances. There are just too few locations in strategic areas across the nation for vans to park.
Figures from the Federal Freeway Administration revealed just a few years in the past there have been about 313,000 parking areas for some 3.5 million vans. Not all these vans require in a single day parking away from their terminals, but it surely’s nonetheless a daunting ratio.
Final fall, telematics and dash-cam provider Lytx compiled an inventory of 20 of the most harmful interstate and on/off ramp areas frequented by parked drivers. Pulled from almost 50,000 truck parking occasions reported/tracked by Lytx in a two-week interval, Pennsylvania, Georgia, and New Jersey ranked within the high 5.
“The info helps to determine areas that have to be checked out and investigated for the issues which can be main drivers to park there,” stated Amir Sultan, the corporate’s lead product supervisor. “There may very well be many causes for it, equivalent to a scarcity of parking areas, emergency conditions, higher monitoring of empty parking spots, and extra. Additional investigations of most of these causes may assist in fixing these issues in an optimum means.”
These areas would clearly be a fantastic place to begin creating extra parking areas, however there’s most likely not rather a lot vacant actual property in these areas. Expropriating land isn’t fashionable, and the NIMBY crowds will do all of their energy to oppose such growth. Nonetheless, we all know the place the issue areas are. Let’s get to work fixing the issues.
Drifting to the Gentle
And I’ll go away you with curiosity. I’m unsure if there may be any analysis to again this up, however I’m satisfied there’s one thing occurring in a half-asleep driver’s mind that truly trigger them to steer towards lights or objects on an in any other case featureless horizon.
Think about what number of crashes contain a single automobile parked alongside a roadway, and even indicators. The chances in opposition to hitting that lone parked automobile randomly are impossibly excessive. There might be miles of open interstate, but a sleepy driver will usually strike a parked automotive or truck. Typical knowledge says the parked automobile ought to go away its lights on so different drivers can see it. What if leaving the lights on really causes inattentive drivers to absentmindedly steer towards a lightweight supply?
On this case, the stretch of roadway resulting in the remainder space is straight and featureless for a few miles. The street curves gently to the appropriate, and the exit ramp to the remainder space properly meshes with the curve within the street. Did the “vibrant lights” of the remainder space by some means appeal to a probably sleepy bus driver (if the driving force was asleep; we nonetheless don’t know that)?
Reporters on the Journal-Occasions of Racine, Wisconsin, compiled some crash statistics that reveal an fascinating image. They notice, “Final 12 months, the California Division of Transportation launched a research displaying that from 2014 to 2018, 1,626 crashes within the state concerned parked vans, leading to 131 deaths. A 2020 research by the Texas Division of Transportation discovered that from 2013 to 2017, 2,315 accidents involving parked vans have been blamed for 138 deaths.”
It has taken an enormous period of time, however Congress not too long ago pledged almost three-quarters of a billion {dollars} to assist with the trucking business’s parking drawback. That public cash funding what is mostly a industrial curiosity. All of us pay to park out automobiles at airports and sporting occasions, and sometimes proper at residence the place we stay. But by some means trucking thinks its parking issues ought to be paid for with the general public purse, one thing I’ve written about earlier than.
If the business actually wish to resolve the parking drawback, it must get used to paying for parking. That’s why there’s a scarcity within the first place. As soon as the personal sector figures out it might make a bit cash from parking, we’ll have all of the parking areas we may ever want.
