Trucking Trade Stories Predictably Weak Q2

[Stay on top of transportation news: Get TTNews in your inbox.]

The trucking trade reported a weak second quarter with freight volumes and destocking efforts placing downward strain on demand.

“I might say from 1 / 4 perspective, it was dangerous,” mentioned Wells Fargo analyst Allison Poliniak-Cusic. “However I don’t assume that was sudden. If I look relative to prior outlooks, volumes fell a bit deeper and pricing is a bit worse and I feel that a few of the corporations anticipated to maintain a few of the positive factors that they made in the course of the pandemic. And clearly shopper stock builds, every part sort of mixed, continues to push these freight dynamics down.”

Poliniak-Cusic added there haven’t been many indicators of an financial restoration. However she has heard dialog round stabilization and whether or not the trade will flip round subsequent yr. She famous that whereas circumstances are nonetheless dangerous, they don’t appear to be getting a lot worse.

“There’s no solution to get round it, issues are weak,” mentioned TD Cowen analyst Jason Seidl. “In all probability a little bit bit weaker than we thought, however not by so much. I feel there’s a prevailing feeling that we’ve already hit the underside. I assume the large query, which stays unanswered, is how shortly can we come off the underside.”

This isn’t a freight- or volume-led restoration. That is actually a supply-led restoration.

Allison Poliniak-Cusic

Citi analyst Christian Wetherbee identified that the truckload facet of the trade was hit hardest. He additionally famous that the outlook for the second half of the yr was difficult for these carriers as nicely. However less-than-truckload has been wanting extra promising, as Yellow Corp.’s declaration of chapter frees up capability and enterprise.

“LTL is a special story,” Wetherbee mentioned. “The numbers weren’t essentially nice for the quarter themselves. They have been most likely positive. However the outlook for the again half was considerably higher due to what’s happening with Yellow.”

Yellow ranks No.13 on the Transport Subjects Prime 100 record of the biggest for-hire carriers in North America and No. 3 on the TT record of the biggest less-than-truckload carriers. The expectation is its market share will shift towards opponents like Previous Dominion Freight Line, ArcBest, XPO or Saia. Wetherbee has even heard from carriers that course of has already began.

“Now there was already a level of underlying enchancment sequentially of their enterprise, which was there in truckloads,” Wetherbee mentioned. “So these tendencies have been constant the place late April, perhaps early Might, appeared to mark the underside after which we noticed enchancment.”

Stifel Capital Markets analyst Bruce Chan identified that destocking efforts have added further downward strain on volumes. The issue is many retailers and warehouses grew to become oversupplied, main them to work down their stock ranges.

“We’d anticipated a heavier destocking interval within the second quarter, which, in fact, would have been a headwind,” Chan mentioned. “The setup was for a reasonably smooth freight surroundings and transferring into what truly transpired, I feel that outcomes have been even weaker than that. What we noticed was a deeper destocking freight pullback than anticipated.”

Chan added that destocking was additional sophisticated by seasonal freight tendencies. He famous that there are particular items which might be solely going to maneuver within the second quarter, so it turns into tough to destock them till then.

“There are indicators that some clients on the trucking facet have gotten by way of their stock corrections,” Seidl mentioned. “That’s some, undoubtedly not all. So, I feel we’ll nonetheless be working by way of the remainder of that within the again half of the yr. However once more, it’s a constructive signal, however I wouldn’t say it’s an overwhelmingly constructive signal.”

Seidl is anticipating a sluggish and lengthy restoration that’s more likely to materialize early subsequent yr. However he additionally doesn’t foresee issues getting a lot worse, particularly charges, having little room to go down.

“Whenever you take a look at the place a few of the charges have been within the quarter and even early on, perhaps 3Q, there’s nowhere for them to actually fall,” Seidl mentioned. “Whenever you’re nonetheless getting some charges on the market within the spot market that don’t even pay for a driver, not to mention all of the overhead, the reply isn’t extra freight at these charges. The reply is healthier charges and in the end, I feel, you’re going to get that from the group. The query is simply how shortly.”

Poliniak-Cusic famous that there was lots of debate amongst her workforce over when the turnaround will occur. A serious drawback is the uncertainty round finish shoppers. She has additionally gotten blended indicators from main retailers with some beginning to restock inventories and others holding off.

“Quite a lot of what you might need heard throughout earnings, too, is this isn’t a freight- or volume-led restoration,” Poliniak-Cusic mentioned. “That is actually a supply-led restoration. That means taking provide out of the market to match that capability with demand. Which might be a few of that stabilization that we’re listening to talked about, that capability beginning to right-size.”