Consultants Share Suggestions for Combating Predatory Towing

[Stay on top of transportation news: Get TTNews in your inbox.]

PHOENIX — States are taking intention at towing firms that stop carriers from accessing cargo in a trailer after a rig has been dropped off after a tow, a panel of insurance coverage consultants stated.

“Having handled a couple of tow truck firms, they’re fairly scary folks,” stated Dean Croke, principal analyst with DAT Freight and Analytics, through the Motor Service Insurance coverage Schooling Basis annual Western Convention on Might 19. “This is a vital difficulty within the trucking business and we have to tackle it.”

Croke was joined by J.W. Taylor, managing companion on the legislation agency of Taylor Johnson, and Tony Bradley, president of the Arizona Trucking Affiliation, in a dialogue that lined the continued downside of towing firms refusing to launch the cargo after they’ve towed a truck in for repairs, and towing prices that may generally creep effectively into five-figure territory. The panelists agreed there are methods the trucking business can efficiently fight these ways.

Taylor harassed that step one is to not be intimidated by a towing firm when its presents a invoice that appears unrealistic.

🤠✨ Thank You for Making the Western Convention an Unforgettable Success! ✨🌟
We want to thank everybody who attended the Western Convention final week. Your presence, engagement, and enthusiasm made this occasion a exceptional success! pic.twitter.com/amnksW79gC

— MCIEF (@MCIEF2) Might 23, 2023

“You’ll be able to say I’m going to name the cops, and the response of the towing firm is, ‘Go forward, please do,’ ” he stated. As an alternative, he stated, a service’s first name must be to its insurance coverage supplier as they’ll typically have rather more leverage.

“Discover out if in case you have towing protection, that is missed so many instances,” he stated.

He additionally urged discovering out what’s permitted underneath native legal guidelines. “This can be a state-by-state query, and that is additionally, generally, [a] municipality difficulty,” Taylor stated.

He cited Florida legislation for instance. “A lien on tools within the state of Florida will not be a lien on the cargo,” he stated. “You’ll be able to demand in Florida that you simply launch all private property that’s not within the car and that features the objects within the trailer, the cargo.”

Croke famous that a number of states have legal guidelines on the books that particularly prohibit towing firms from holding cargo, and different states are taking comparable motion. In Maryland, for instance, Gov. Wes Moore on Might 16 signed a invoice that establishes a committee that may set particular charges for police-initiated towing of medium- and heavy-duty vehicles.

Bradley stated state trucking associations may also assist.

“If in case you have examples of utmost towing payments, convey them ahead,” he stated. “In the event you present that you simply acquired charged $68,000 for an hour and half of labor and so they held [your] load, please convey this stuff ahead. Present us the ridiculous invoice [and] allow us to run with it from there.”

The problem has develop into a much bigger one for trucking; the American Transportation Analysis Institute has made predatory towing a prime 5 difficulty that it researches this yr.

Extra broadly, panelists urged motor carriers to guard themselves from these and different sorts of dangers by using finest practices when it comes to security and compliance.

“Managing threat isn’t just shopping for an insurance coverage coverage. There may be much more you must do nowadays to handle the underlying dangers,” Croke stated. “Managing threat is a really complicated factor and the info factors are there in the event you select to look.”

For instance, he famous that sustaining extra predictable schedules for drivers will help enhance security. He cited digital logging machine knowledge that signifies that drivers who begin their work days throughout totally different begin instances throughout every week or have rotating shifts typically are at the next fee of threat than drivers who routinely begin on the identical time.

“The ELD knowledge reveals the motive force’s begin time day by day, and you may see it’s the most predictive knowledge round,” he stated. “If it’s 2 a.m., then 6 a.m., then midnight over the course of every week, that may destroy a driver’s sleep time.”

Efficient record-keeping additionally will help defend motor carriers, particularly in an age of so-called “nuclear verdicts,” outlined by ATRI as those who lead to a judgment of greater than $10 million. The panel took questions on this particular matter.

“It’s vital for firms to have a correct knowledge and retention coverage so an lawyer can not use the info to current you to the jury as a foul actor,” Taylor emphasised. “Don’t be afraid of the info — use the info to enhance your organization.”